So-so Ad Blitz

The Super Bowl has come and gone. I have to confess that I am not a big football fan, so the game, while interesting, was not a priority for me. The commercials were a different story.

Overall, I was a bit letdown. There were several commercials that were reasonably enjoyable, but really did not stand out. Sure, it was funny to Richard Simmons almost get run down like a deer in the headlights. It just was not all that spectacular.

And do not get me started on that awful Pepsuber spot. Either the joke was so far above my head or else it was way, way below any good standard of humor. Really, if you are going to hire Richard Dean Anderson to spoof MacGyver with some SNL cast members, utilize the moment. I would have gotten a good laugh out of MacGyver in a series of spots showcasing his character solving huge problems with Pepsi.

"MacGyver, the nuclear reactor is about to meltdown!"

"No worries, with some chewing gum, baking soda, and Pepsi we can..."

You get the idea. I would have enjoyed that far more. As it was, the commercial struck me as a waste. The PepsiMax commercial with the "Guys can take anything" tag was much better. Good slapstick comedy. Sometimes, the basics are best.

The Careerbuilder.com ad was great though! Good blend of real job frustrations mixed with the absurd to get their point across. Just nicely done all around.

I am just old enough to have vague memories of Johnny Carson and Ed McMahon on the Tonight Show. Seeing Ed resorting to plugging a gold buying site was depressing. MC Hammer's appearance in the spot? Not so much.

Clearly, a campaign requires a lot of talent to come together in order to take shape. If some of the bad efforts were just attempts to generate buzz of any kind, I think that misses the point of advertising. Its cheap and does nothing to elevate the standard or, in my opinion, the brand. More than just the writers behind the copy at fault though.

To the entertaining ads, bravo! To the duds, better luck next year, if you happen to make it.